This review contains spoilers if you have not read Changes, Book 12!! Ye have been warned.
*Book source
~ Library
Title ~ Ghost Story
Series ~ The Dresden Files, #13
Author ~ Jim Butcher
Narrator ~ John Glover
Publisher ~ Penguin Audio
Published ~ 26 July 2011
Genre ~ Fantasy | Paranormal | Mystery
Length ~ 17 hrs 56 minutes
Our Rating ~ 5 bites
Narration ~ 1 bite
Harry
Dresden, wizard extraordinaire, private investigator, defender of Chicago and…ghost.
After being shot and falling into icy Lake Michigan Harry wakes up to find
himself back in Chicago .
Only it’s not Chicago .
Not exactly. And he has a mission should he choose to accept it. He must find
out who murdered him and restore the balance. With his friends’ lives on the
line, of course Harry rushes in where angels fear to tread. Ok, they don’t fear
to tread in the spirit world, but it sounded good. Go with it.
Guest
Reviewers:
A
~ my 17-yr-old daughter
T
~ my 15-yr-old son
K
~ my 14-yr-old son
First
off, the title sort of gives this book away. After the ending to Changes it’s fairly obvious where this
one is heading. We enjoyed the book quite a lot, but have to admit it’s not a
favorite. There is a lot of blah, blah, blah going on amongst all the good
stuff, but instead of a 4 we gave it a 5 because it was kinda cool to have a
story involving Harry as a ghost.
The
plot is a bit murky, but we went with it. Old favorite characters are back and
some new ones are introduced. Mortimer is a bit of a dweeb in the beginning,
but we really like how he grows and steps up toward the end. Butters is a bit
of a surprise. Who knew the little guy was so damn smart? I mean, we love him
and he’s proven he’s got balls, but he really shines in this book. Sir Stuart
is awesome.
T
loved how we got to see many of Harry’s memories and K thought seeing inside
Bob’s skull was pretty cool. We were all surprised at the effect destroying the
Red Court
had. A perfect example of not thinking something all the way through. Everyone loved the whole Star Trek scene,
Uriel’s seven words, Harry’s speech at the end and the ending itself.
Now
I must address the narration. We were not happy with the change in narrator. At
all. Period. *emphatic nodding* While we agree that John Glover has a pleasant
voice and we would be happy to listen to other
books he reads, after 12 books in the Dresden universe narrated by James
Marsters, we just couldn’t wrap our
heads around a totally different take on the characters and off-sounding
secondary characters by a new narrator. The entire book grated on our nerves. We
feel bad for Mr. Glover, walking into the middle of an established beloved
series, but we like what we like and we did not
like his version. End of story.
Favorite
quotes:
“Star
Trek?” I asked her. “Really?”
“What?” she demanded, bending unnaturally black eyebrows together.
“There are two kinds of people in the universe, Molly,” I said. “Star Trek fans and Star Wars fans. This is shocking.”
She sniffed. “This is the post-nerd-closet world, Harry. It’s okay to like both.”
“Blasphemy and lies,” I said.
**********************************************************************
“My gast was pretty well flabbered.” (hehe I use this one once in awhile.)
**********************************************************************
“Jump into an open grave? What kind of idiot are you?"
Butters replied. "I might as well put on a red shirt and volunteer for the
away team. There's snow and ice and slippery mud down there. That's like asking
for an ironically broken neck.”
*****************************************************************
Courage
is about learning how to function despite the fear, to put aside your instincts
to run or give in completely to the anger born from fear. Courage is about
using your brain and your heart when every cell of your body is screaming at
you to fight or flee - and then following through on what you believe is the
right thing to do.
Star Trek fan here ! Like I always say, I need to catch up on that series and I understand why you're upset, James Marsters did a great job narrating these novels :)
ReplyDeleteI like both, but I think I like Star Trek a smidge better. lol Yeah, we were not happy. :(
DeleteSo I decided to skip the review for now, since I've still only read book 1. But I love that yall read this together and it's great that everyone is enjoying it. I need to step on it - something I realize I say every time yall review one of these... Too many books! LOL
ReplyDeleteLOL I know! I say it all the damn time! So many books I need to read and series I need to catch up on. *sigh*
DeleteI just skimmed it cause I am only on book 5 but WHAT! They changed narrators. :( Now I am not look forward to this one..I like James Marsters..he is Dresden. :(
ReplyDeleteYep. We pushed through it, but we weren't happy about it. Luckily, that's the only one not narrated by him. At least, for now.
DeleteOh that is unfortunate about the narrator. I wonder why they did that?! I'd planned on listening to these just for James. lol
ReplyDeleteMarsters wasn't available at the time. They should have waited. It was awful. John Glover has a pleasant voice, but he is *not* Marsters. An established series should never change a narrator unless it's absolutely unavoidable. Like, the narrator died. That's it.
Delete